Construction Defects in New York; Part 5 of 6 - Improper Installation

John Caravella Esq.
July 31, 2012 — 1,073 views  

This is a continuing article series on construction defects in New York, These include an introduction (part 1), design defects (part 2), defective construction (part 3), improper materials (part 4), improper installations (part 5) and finally important time limitations which apply to seeking legal action for defective construction in New York (part 6).

Construction defects relating to materials can also be based on their installation. If products are installed incorrectly this can result in an unacceptable condition to the project owner. (Subcontractors would be wise to always review and follow the manufacturer’s installation instructions for the materials they are installing). Plumbing installations are often examples of improper installation. Although the type of pipes used may be correct to the contract, significant plumbing problems could result if they are not pitched correctly in their installation.

Improper installations also pose a large risk of liability to the architects or engineers who are contracted to supervise the work. For example, an engineer was found liable for the installation of faulty anchor bolts when the engineer was aware of this improper installation and this defect caused a steel column to fall, resulting in the death of a construction worker.[1]

Often issues relating to leaking roofs are split between those claiming materials to be defective and those claiming defective installation are the cause of the leak. A good example of how poor installation techniques on the part of the roof installer can create a defective roof can be seen in this youtube video, where a roof installation is examined to determine cause of leakage.

One of the most common reasons for skylight leaks is poor fitting due to inadequate installation. Installing a skylight requires precision and skill, as generally is beyond the skill level of most homeowners and should be done by a roofing professional.

The determination of whether a faulty condition is the result of defective materials or is the result of defective installation can only be made by qualified engineering inspections. Should any legal claims be necessary to recover these resulting damages, a written engineering report is the best method for establishing the defective conditions. Engineering reports of defective construction can be submitted to the court as evidence and your engineer can provide testimony as to their findings of the defective conditions observed. This testimony can include their recommendations on how best to correct these defects.

John Caravella Esq.

The Law Offices of John Caravella, P.C.

Mr. Caravella, a construction attorney admitted to practice in all NY and FL state courts, represents architects, contractors, sub-contractors, engineers & owners in all phases of construction. He has education & working experience in architecture.